Handy and Brushy are walking along when they come upon Nutty, who is selling books. Handy decides to buy Brushy a book that resembles an agonized face. Later that night Handy reads the book to Brusy, causing clouds to swirl over their house and birds to fall out of the sky. As Handy leaves, Flaky closes the window and turns out the lights, leaving a terrified Brushy alone in the darkness. A strange, ominous glow appears in Brushy's room, and when she looks down to see what it is, she is attacked by an unseen force.
The next morning Flaky makes breakfast for Brushy, who is now green and in a zombie-like state. After refusing to eat her breakfast, Brushy's head rotates 360 degrees and Brushy vomits a green fluid all over Flaky. Nails walks out into the kitchen and is then slapped by a tentacle. The doorbell rings and Flaky answers the door to see Breezy, selling cookies. Suddenly, a tentacle wraps itself around Breezy and pulls her offscreen. We now see that Brushy has tenacles and a beak coming out of her head. While Breezy clings for dear life on a cabinet under the sink, the monster in Brushy's head tears the skin and tail off of Breezy lower body. She manages to escape into the area beneath the sink. She starts crying from the possible pain she's enduring or from fear or possibly for both reasons, but the tentacles emerge through the pipes and grab her again. The tentacles attempt to drag Breezy through the drain of the sink, crushing her body in the process. When she gets stuck, the tentacles use the garbage disposal to grind up her body, bringing her cries of pain and fear to an end. While the beak begins eating Breezy's mangled remains, a panic-stricken Flaky places a phone call.
The doorbell rings again and Flaky answers to find Baldy, a priest/exorcist. He is immediately vomited upon by Brushy, who he then tackles. Baldy struggles with the monster in Brushy's head and eventually succeeds in tearing it out. Brushy, now her normal color and minus the monster in his head, looks at her body and smiles happily. Unfortunately, Flaky, not realizing that Brushy has been cured, continuously hits Brushy with a shovel until she is a flat, bloody circle. Later, Flaky and Baldy stand at Brushy's grave, mourning her death. Before the episode ends, a tentacle comes out of Baldy's beak, which he quickly places a hand over.
- Numerous birds die after Handy reads the cursed book to Brushy.
- Breezy is pulled through the drain of a sink and is torn apart by the garbage disposal.
- Brushy is hit and flattened by Flaky, using a shovel.